Loading

Annals of Community Medicine and Practice

Euthanasia in Patients with Dementia

Case Report | Open Access

  • 1. Expertise centrum Euthanasie, Netherlands
+ Show More - Show Less
Corresponding Authors
Sytske van der Meer, Expertise centrum Euthanasie P.O. Box 13480 2501 EL The Hague, Netherlands.
Abstract

Even though there is at present in The Netherlands a widely accepted legal framework within which euthanasia is allowed, many doctors find euthanasia in cases of dementia too complex. There are several reasons for this cautious approach. Doctors fear the possibility of a judicial aftermath. Another factor is a faulty, if not downright mistaken, opinion about the nature of the mental anguish that people with dementia sometimes experience. Doctors find it difficult to realize just why dementia can be so terrible. A further reason for this restraint is the problem of deciding whether the patient is mentally still competent when it comes to formulating a wish to die.

Citation

van der Meer S, Keizer B (2020) Euthanasia in Patients with Dementia. Ann Community Med Pract 5(1): 1045.

CASE HISTORIES

Patient A was 72 years old when her son brought her into contact with the Expertisecentre for Euthanasia. She had been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease 18 months earlier. Her GP was unwilling to arrange euthanasia for her, because he did not agree that the woman’s suffering was all that severe. We had four meetings with the patient during which her son and her daughter were alternately present. The patient lived in a lovely cottage, which was only possible because of the help offered by her children and her sister-in-law, who lived right next-door. In earlier times she was a hardworking woman, who ran her own restaurant with thorough efficiency, never shirking to wait at table herself in busy times. Now she had turned into a slow-witted, nervous, shuffling old lady, always afraid of falling. Alzheimer’s disease had gradually robbed her of the thing she valued most in life: living her own life, not having to depend on others. Driving her car had become impossible. She also had to give up her bicycle after some nasty falls. She was no longer capable of preparing a meal. She kept on going to the supermarket but felt ashamed when she came back home with useless purchases she didn’t need at all.

Her character changed, she lost her temper easily, which was not her usual way of dealing with people. She once got into a row with the cashier in the supermarket. She had visited the shop a couple of times to buy new batteries for her house-telephone. She said the cashier did not put the batteries in her shopping bag. But at home her son chanced on a huge store of new batteries. Two boys in the neighborhood who used to help her in the garden stopped their involvement because she was unkind to them, shouting abuse for no reason.

She was not always fully aware of these details of her decline, but it all added up to a feeling of increasing despair. She was no longer capable of a deeply probing exchange about these developments. But she remained adamant on one point. She realized that she was on her way to the situation in which her mother ended: she died in a care home, deeply demented, lying in bed in a fetal position, wearing diapers because of her incontinence. She repeatedly voiced her fear that she might be too late with her request, too far gone to request euthanasia.

The second opinion doctor agreed that her request fell within the bounds of the law. We were worried whether she could set a date for the event, but after the second opinion she proposed a date two weeks later. She was greatly relieved by the prospect of her demise and on the appointed day she imbibed the lethal potion without much ado.

Patient B was 67 years old when his son got in touch with the Expertisecentre for Euthanasia. He had been diagnosed with Lewy Body Dementia a year earlier. The patient worked as a lorry driver until he was 48 when he was found to be unfit for employment due to trouble with his back. He had little formal education and was verbally not very proficient.

But when we first met, he easily managed to explain to us that he wanted to die, and as soon as possible. He was an ardent cyclist, covering considerable distances. But it happened time and again that he lost his way, and on several occasions he was completely lost. This irritated his wife, she blamed him for his incompetence. Gradually he lost his independence, needing help when getting out of bed, washing himself, putting on clothes and visiting the toilet. His wife found this hard to cope with. There was a reversal of roles. He used to be the one in charge, but now he totally depended on her. She shared her misgivings with other people in the neighbourhood. The GP found all this rather difficult and felt it wise to ask the Expertise centre for Euthanasia to deal with his request.

During our visits we met a deeply unhappy man. He was quite well aware of his situation and told us his fear of further deterioration. He could hardly stand, walking was almost impossible. His verbal range was severely diminished which caused extra anxiety at the prospect of no longer being able to express his wish for euthanasia. He lost his way in his own house, another cause of tension and unrest.

All he wanted to do was sit in his chair all day. His wife was slightly relieved when we explained to her that we realized that she too was suffering badly on account of her husband’s disease. We visited the couple four times within a relatively short time span. During two of our visits their son was present. The second opinion doctor found the case to be well within the bounds of the law. Six weeks after our first contact the patient, greatly relieved and with firm determination, drank the lethal medication,.

DISCUSSION

A careful exploration of the inner life of a person suffering from dementia enables the doctor to come to a reasonable estimate of how horrible the condition can be in some cases. People battling with dementia, the word is very apt, often fight against a threatening way of being lost. It is not just a matter of being lost in a strange town, they cannot even find their way in their own home, and worse still, they have lost the way within themselves. Often they do not remember who they were. They wonder who they are now, and what is to become of them. Not all people suffering from dementia experience these mental upheavals with the same agonizing intensity. But those who, to a certain extent, realize what is happening to them, may not unrealistically regard a request for euthanasia as the only way out.

Mental competence

Assessing mental competence in dementia patients who put in a request for euthanasia is difficult at times. The criteria suggested by Appelbaum and Grisso offer a good guideline table 1. It is important to realize that any pronouncement about mental competence must be linked to a specific issue, in this context: the wish to have one’s life ended. Does the patient understand what he or she requests? Is there a realization what the request implies, for himself or herself, and also for his or her loved ones? And most of all: is the request durable?

In people suffering from dementia there is always the danger of losing this competence. The Dutch euthanasia law states explicitly that a written advance directive, in which the person describes under which conditions euthanasia is to be granted him or her, may take the place of an oral request. In 2016 a Dutch doctor working in a nursing home euthanized a woman suffering from Alzheimer’s disease, even though at the time of her death she was no longer capable of voicing a request. The doctor acted on the base of her actual suffering and on the text of the advance directive. Understandably there was a lively national debate about this particular case. The doctor was exonerated in court. In April 2020 the Dutch Supreme Court upheld this judgment. We are here confronted with a devastating problem that is continually debated by people suffering from dementia and people who fear dementia in their future. It is also an issue that engages many philosophers, ethicists, medical professionals, lawyers, judges end politicians [1-6].

Table 1: Criteria of Appelbaum and Grisso for the assessment of mental competence.

There are 4 cognitive capacities which should be within the mental scope of a person who one would describe as mentally competent.
1. Capable of choosing between 2 treatment options and uttering that choice.
2. Capable of understanding proffered information.
3. Capable of realizing the nature of the situation (awareness of one’s own situation).
4. Capable of rationally weighing information (reason logically).

 

CONCLUSION

In The Netherlands euthanasia is legally allowed in certain cases of dementia. However, many doctors regard the issue as too complex. A thorough exploration of the mental state of persons suffering from dementia, enables one to arrive at a reasonably accurate weighing of the severity of the mental anguish. The guidelines formulated by Appelbaum and Grisso may be used when assessing the mental competence of the patient. In this way it is possible in The Netherlands to act on the request for euthanasia from a patient wrestling with dementia within the bounds of Dutch law.

van der Meer S, Keizer B (2020) Euthanasia in Patients with Dementia. Ann Community Med Pract 5(1): 1045.

Received : 16 Sep 2020
Accepted : 01 Oct 2020
Published : 02 Oct 2020
Journals
Annals of Otolaryngology and Rhinology
ISSN : 2379-948X
Launched : 2014
JSM Schizophrenia
Launched : 2016
Journal of Nausea
Launched : 2020
JSM Internal Medicine
Launched : 2016
JSM Hepatitis
Launched : 2016
JSM Oro Facial Surgeries
ISSN : 2578-3211
Launched : 2016
Journal of Human Nutrition and Food Science
ISSN : 2333-6706
Launched : 2013
JSM Regenerative Medicine and Bioengineering
ISSN : 2379-0490
Launched : 2013
JSM Spine
ISSN : 2578-3181
Launched : 2016
Archives of Palliative Care
ISSN : 2573-1165
Launched : 2016
JSM Nutritional Disorders
ISSN : 2578-3203
Launched : 2017
Annals of Neurodegenerative Disorders
ISSN : 2476-2032
Launched : 2016
Journal of Fever
ISSN : 2641-7782
Launched : 2017
JSM Bone Marrow Research
ISSN : 2578-3351
Launched : 2016
JSM Mathematics and Statistics
ISSN : 2578-3173
Launched : 2014
Journal of Autoimmunity and Research
ISSN : 2573-1173
Launched : 2014
JSM Arthritis
ISSN : 2475-9155
Launched : 2016
JSM Head and Neck Cancer-Cases and Reviews
ISSN : 2573-1610
Launched : 2016
JSM General Surgery Cases and Images
ISSN : 2573-1564
Launched : 2016
JSM Anatomy and Physiology
ISSN : 2573-1262
Launched : 2016
JSM Dental Surgery
ISSN : 2573-1548
Launched : 2016
Annals of Emergency Surgery
ISSN : 2573-1017
Launched : 2016
Annals of Mens Health and Wellness
ISSN : 2641-7707
Launched : 2017
Journal of Preventive Medicine and Health Care
ISSN : 2576-0084
Launched : 2018
Journal of Chronic Diseases and Management
ISSN : 2573-1300
Launched : 2016
Annals of Vaccines and Immunization
ISSN : 2378-9379
Launched : 2014
JSM Heart Surgery Cases and Images
ISSN : 2578-3157
Launched : 2016
Annals of Reproductive Medicine and Treatment
ISSN : 2573-1092
Launched : 2016
JSM Brain Science
ISSN : 2573-1289
Launched : 2016
JSM Biomarkers
ISSN : 2578-3815
Launched : 2014
JSM Biology
ISSN : 2475-9392
Launched : 2016
Archives of Stem Cell and Research
ISSN : 2578-3580
Launched : 2014
Annals of Clinical and Medical Microbiology
ISSN : 2578-3629
Launched : 2014
JSM Pediatric Surgery
ISSN : 2578-3149
Launched : 2017
Journal of Memory Disorder and Rehabilitation
ISSN : 2578-319X
Launched : 2016
JSM Tropical Medicine and Research
ISSN : 2578-3165
Launched : 2016
JSM Head and Face Medicine
ISSN : 2578-3793
Launched : 2016
JSM Cardiothoracic Surgery
ISSN : 2573-1297
Launched : 2016
JSM Bone and Joint Diseases
ISSN : 2578-3351
Launched : 2017
JSM Bioavailability and Bioequivalence
ISSN : 2641-7812
Launched : 2017
JSM Atherosclerosis
ISSN : 2573-1270
Launched : 2016
Journal of Genitourinary Disorders
ISSN : 2641-7790
Launched : 2017
Journal of Fractures and Sprains
ISSN : 2578-3831
Launched : 2016
Journal of Autism and Epilepsy
ISSN : 2641-7774
Launched : 2016
Annals of Marine Biology and Research
ISSN : 2573-105X
Launched : 2014
JSM Health Education & Primary Health Care
ISSN : 2578-3777
Launched : 2016
JSM Communication Disorders
ISSN : 2578-3807
Launched : 2016
Annals of Musculoskeletal Disorders
ISSN : 2578-3599
Launched : 2016
Annals of Virology and Research
ISSN : 2573-1122
Launched : 2014
JSM Renal Medicine
ISSN : 2573-1637
Launched : 2016
Journal of Muscle Health
ISSN : 2578-3823
Launched : 2016
JSM Genetics and Genomics
ISSN : 2334-1823
Launched : 2013
JSM Anxiety and Depression
ISSN : 2475-9139
Launched : 2016
Clinical Journal of Heart Diseases
ISSN : 2641-7766
Launched : 2016
Annals of Medicinal Chemistry and Research
ISSN : 2378-9336
Launched : 2014
JSM Pain and Management
ISSN : 2578-3378
Launched : 2016
JSM Women's Health
ISSN : 2578-3696
Launched : 2016
Clinical Research in HIV or AIDS
ISSN : 2374-0094
Launched : 2013
Journal of Endocrinology, Diabetes and Obesity
ISSN : 2333-6692
Launched : 2013
Journal of Substance Abuse and Alcoholism
ISSN : 2373-9363
Launched : 2013
JSM Neurosurgery and Spine
ISSN : 2373-9479
Launched : 2013
Journal of Liver and Clinical Research
ISSN : 2379-0830
Launched : 2014
Journal of Drug Design and Research
ISSN : 2379-089X
Launched : 2014
JSM Clinical Oncology and Research
ISSN : 2373-938X
Launched : 2013
JSM Bioinformatics, Genomics and Proteomics
ISSN : 2576-1102
Launched : 2014
JSM Chemistry
ISSN : 2334-1831
Launched : 2013
Journal of Trauma and Care
ISSN : 2573-1246
Launched : 2014
JSM Surgical Oncology and Research
ISSN : 2578-3688
Launched : 2016
Annals of Food Processing and Preservation
ISSN : 2573-1033
Launched : 2016
Journal of Radiology and Radiation Therapy
ISSN : 2333-7095
Launched : 2013
JSM Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
ISSN : 2578-3572
Launched : 2016
Annals of Clinical Pathology
ISSN : 2373-9282
Launched : 2013
Annals of Cardiovascular Diseases
ISSN : 2641-7731
Launched : 2016
Journal of Behavior
ISSN : 2576-0076
Launched : 2016
Annals of Clinical and Experimental Metabolism
ISSN : 2572-2492
Launched : 2016
Clinical Research in Infectious Diseases
ISSN : 2379-0636
Launched : 2013
JSM Microbiology
ISSN : 2333-6455
Launched : 2013
Journal of Urology and Research
ISSN : 2379-951X
Launched : 2014
Journal of Family Medicine and Community Health
ISSN : 2379-0547
Launched : 2013
Annals of Pregnancy and Care
ISSN : 2578-336X
Launched : 2017
JSM Cell and Developmental Biology
ISSN : 2379-061X
Launched : 2013
Annals of Aquaculture and Research
ISSN : 2379-0881
Launched : 2014
Clinical Research in Pulmonology
ISSN : 2333-6625
Launched : 2013
Journal of Immunology and Clinical Research
ISSN : 2333-6714
Launched : 2013
Annals of Forensic Research and Analysis
ISSN : 2378-9476
Launched : 2014
JSM Biochemistry and Molecular Biology
ISSN : 2333-7109
Launched : 2013
Annals of Breast Cancer Research
ISSN : 2641-7685
Launched : 2016
Annals of Gerontology and Geriatric Research
ISSN : 2378-9409
Launched : 2014
Journal of Sleep Medicine and Disorders
ISSN : 2379-0822
Launched : 2014
JSM Burns and Trauma
ISSN : 2475-9406
Launched : 2016
Chemical Engineering and Process Techniques
ISSN : 2333-6633
Launched : 2013
Annals of Clinical Cytology and Pathology
ISSN : 2475-9430
Launched : 2014
JSM Allergy and Asthma
ISSN : 2573-1254
Launched : 2016
Journal of Neurological Disorders and Stroke
ISSN : 2334-2307
Launched : 2013
Annals of Sports Medicine and Research
ISSN : 2379-0571
Launched : 2014
JSM Sexual Medicine
ISSN : 2578-3718
Launched : 2016
Annals of Vascular Medicine and Research
ISSN : 2378-9344
Launched : 2014
JSM Biotechnology and Biomedical Engineering
ISSN : 2333-7117
Launched : 2013
Journal of Hematology and Transfusion
ISSN : 2333-6684
Launched : 2013
JSM Environmental Science and Ecology
ISSN : 2333-7141
Launched : 2013
Journal of Cardiology and Clinical Research
ISSN : 2333-6676
Launched : 2013
JSM Nanotechnology and Nanomedicine
ISSN : 2334-1815
Launched : 2013
Journal of Ear, Nose and Throat Disorders
ISSN : 2475-9473
Launched : 2016
JSM Ophthalmology
ISSN : 2333-6447
Launched : 2013
Journal of Pharmacology and Clinical Toxicology
ISSN : 2333-7079
Launched : 2013
Annals of Psychiatry and Mental Health
ISSN : 2374-0124
Launched : 2013
Medical Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology
ISSN : 2333-6439
Launched : 2013
Annals of Pediatrics and Child Health
ISSN : 2373-9312
Launched : 2013
JSM Clinical Pharmaceutics
ISSN : 2379-9498
Launched : 2014
JSM Foot and Ankle
ISSN : 2475-9112
Launched : 2016
JSM Alzheimer's Disease and Related Dementia
ISSN : 2378-9565
Launched : 2014
Journal of Addiction Medicine and Therapy
ISSN : 2333-665X
Launched : 2013
Journal of Veterinary Medicine and Research
ISSN : 2378-931X
Launched : 2013
Annals of Public Health and Research
ISSN : 2378-9328
Launched : 2014
Annals of Orthopedics and Rheumatology
ISSN : 2373-9290
Launched : 2013
Journal of Clinical Nephrology and Research
ISSN : 2379-0652
Launched : 2014
Annals of Biometrics and Biostatistics
ISSN : 2374-0116
Launched : 2013
JSM Clinical Case Reports
ISSN : 2373-9819
Launched : 2013
Journal of Cancer Biology and Research
ISSN : 2373-9436
Launched : 2013
Journal of Surgery and Transplantation Science
ISSN : 2379-0911
Launched : 2013
Journal of Dermatology and Clinical Research
ISSN : 2373-9371
Launched : 2013
JSM Gastroenterology and Hepatology
ISSN : 2373-9487
Launched : 2013
Annals of Nursing and Practice
ISSN : 2379-9501
Launched : 2014
JSM Dentistry
ISSN : 2333-7133
Launched : 2013
Author Information X