Molecular Insight into Polarity-Mediated Lamina Outgrowt
- 1. Department of Plant and Soil Sciences, Institute for Agricultural Biosciences, Oklahoma State University, USA
Citation
Tadege M (2013) Molecular Insight into Polarity-Mediated Lamina Outgrowth. Int J Plant Biol Res 1(1): 1005.
Editorial
The leaf lamina (blade) is a highly organized photosynthetic structure in which cells in the upper (adaxial) and lower (abaxial) surfaces are morphologically different associated with different functional specializations. The adaxial palisade mesophyll cells are specialized for solar energy capture and the abaxial spongy mesophyll cells are specialized for gas exchange, while the vascular bundles in the middle mesophyll are specialized for water and nutrient translocation in which the water and minerals conducting xylem vessels are positioned adaxial to the sugar transporting phloem. Because the lamina is essentially a solar panel where energy from the sun and carbon dioxide from the atmosphere are assimilated into chemical energy (sugars), its size and design are of fundamental interest to biology from the point of view of form, function, and environmental fitness. Leaf primordia are determinate lateral organs and arise from a small group of pluripotent stem cells in the shoot apical meristem (SAM). Once the leaf primordium initial cells are recruited from the SAM, the primordium organizes itself into well-defined cell layers through meticulously orchestrated cell division, cell expansion, and cell differentiation patterns forming a flattened blade with three distinct axes: proximodistal (length), mediolateral (width), and dorsoventral (thickness). How such a highly organized structure develops from undifferentiated cells of the SAM is a fundamental question in plant developmental biology.
Leaf primordium is initiated from the peripheral region of the SAM, perhaps specified by PIN- FORMED1 (PIN1) polarity-directed auxin maxima [1,2]. This process requires down-regulation of Class I KNOTTED1-like home box (KNOX1) genes at the initiation site [3]. In the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana, KNOX1 members (STM, BP/KNAT1, KNAT2, and KNAT6) play important roles in the establishment and maintenance of the SAM [3-7]. KNOX1 genes promote meristematic activity by modulating the activity of phytohormones; activating cytokinin and repressing gibberellin biosynthesis [8-10], but they are removed from the emerging leaf primordium by factors that promote cell differentiation, primarily by repression with the ASSYMETRIC LEAVES2 (AS2) and AS1 complex [11-16] although they are reactivated in the leaf primordia of species with compound leaves [17,18]. Once the leaf primordium is established, polarity patterning along the dorsoventral (adaxial/abaxial) axis plays a critical role for lamina outgrowth. The origin of polarity is supposed to be a SAM-generated instructive signal [19,20] called the Sussex signal but its identity is unknown and even its existence is questioned by some. However, it is well established that juxtaposition of adaxial and abaxial cells is a prerequisite for proper development and expansion of the lamina [6,21-23], analogous to the dorsal and ventral cells in the imaginal discs of Drosophila wing development [24].
Growth and cell differentiation in the adaxial and abaxial domain of the primordium is controlled by distinct regulatory factors. In Arabidopsis, the Class III Homeodomain Leucine Zipper (HD- ZIP III) family genes PHABULOSA (PHB), PHAVOLUTA (PHV), REVOLUTA (REV), and the LOB-domain family gene AS2 are expressed in the adaxial cells and promote adaxial identity [25- 30]. Meanwhile, the KANADI (KAN1, 2, 3), YABBY (FIL, YAB2, 3, 5) family genes, and AUXIN RESPONSE FACTORS (ARF3/ETT and ARF4) are expressed in the abaxial cells and promote the abaxial identity [31-35]. The adaxial and abaxial factors antagonistically regulate each other in multiple feedback loops to prevent activity across the boundary domain. The HD- ZIP III genes repress KAN in the adaxial domain, while KAN genes repress HD-ZIP III expression in the abaxial domain. Similarly, AS2 represses KAN1 and ARF3/ETT expression in the adaxial domain [36] and in return KAN1 represses AS2 expression in the abaxial domain [37]. A subset of this exquisite regulation is achieved through microRNAs (miRNAs) which also exhibit domain specific expression patterns. The miR165/166 is expressed in the abaxial side and degrades HD-ZIP III transcripts in the abaxial domain via mRNA cleavage [38-40], while adaxially expressed transacting small interfering RNA (tasiR-ARF) derived from the TAS3 gene via the action of miR390 degrades ARF3 and ARF4 mRNA in the adaxial domain [41-43]. The balance of adaxial and abaxial activities through these mutually exclusive expression patterns and strictly reinforced border demarcations is important for flat lamina formation. Several polarity mutants showed that adaxialized or abaxialized primordia lead to malformed lamina including rods and curls although some species with unifacial leaves have flattened abaxialized lamina [44].
Nevertheless, not all leaf polarity factors are always on either side of the aisle. For example, AS1 is an adaxial factor that forms a complex with AS2 to repress KNOX1 activity in leaves. In fact, AS1 is homolog of the snapdragon gene PHANTASTICA (PHAN), the first described polarity gene, whose loss-of-function mutant is characterized by temperature sensitive abaxialized and radialized lamina in the upper leaves [45]. But AS1 is expressed in most parts of the cotyledon, except the cotyledon epidermis, and in the middle of the adaxial and abaxial region of leaf primordia [14]. Likewise, the expression pattern of FILAMENTOUS FLOWER (FIL) shows changes at different stages of development and for the most part extends from the abaxial domain well into the central region resulting in a broader expression domain than KAN [34, 35,46]. Furthermore, it has been recently reported that FIL and miR165/166 are initially expressed all over the initiating primordium at P0 stage and expression gradually shifts and becomes restricted to the abaxial side where FIL expressing miR165/166 free central region and FIL expressing miR165/166 active abaxial region become evident at later stages [47]. The timing of this shifting appears to be important for polarity patterning and is controlled by a plastid- generated retrograde signal [47] whose identity is unclear although candidates may be on the horizon [48]. We may have progressed from the meristem-derived to a plastid-derived signal in search of the elusive adaxializing factor, but whether the plastid-generated adaxializing signal requires the SAM and represents the Sussex signal or depends on differentiated cells from the primordium itself and represents a self-organizing signal remains to be shown. It is possible that the Sussex signal could originate in the leaf primordium and may have a self-patterning power, but may need to communicate with the meristem to generate a gradient dependent signal. Further research is needed to uncover the identity and source of the adaxializing factor.
In addition to domain specific transcription factors and miRNAs, recent data suggested that chromatin modification pathways may also be involved synergizing with the activities of at least some of the polarity factors. AS1 has been reported to associate with HISTONE DEACETYLASE6 (HDA6) in the regulation of Class I KNOX genes [49]. More recently, the AS1-AS2 complex is reported to physically interact and recruit the chromatin remodeling factor, Polycomb repressive complex 2 (PRC2) to stably silence BP and KNAT2 in differentiated leaves [50]. The PRC2 complex has a methyltransferase activity and catalyzes trimethylation at lysine 27 of histone H3 (H3K27me3) associated with chromatin silencing [51-53]. The association of histone modifiers with the HD-ZIP III and KAN genes has not yet been reported and whether chromatin modification regulates lamina outgrowth through leaf polarity patterning is unknown. Most of the polarity factors including AS2 and KAN are involved in the activation of either adaxial or abaxial characteristics, respectively, which requires cell differentiation but not necessarily cell proliferation. Obviously, lamina outgrowth requires both cell proliferation and cell differentiation, but the polarity factors have not been directly linked to activation of cell proliferation or to factors that control these processes such as the cell cycle. In fact, AS2 and KAN repress cell proliferation in their respective domains [25]. This raises the question, how is cell proliferation coordinated with polarity factors? More importantly, as the leaf primordium (which in Arabidopsis contains about a dozen initial cells) grows away from the meristem, how are the proliferating cells maintained for sustained leaf growth?
In the legume model plant Medicago truncatula, a WUSCHEL-like transcription factor called STENOFOLIA (STF) is required for lamina outgrowth (mediolateral growth) as demonstrated by the stf loss-of-function mutant phenotype, which is characterized by a severely reduced narrow lamina [54, 55]. STF is homologue of the WUSCHEL-related homeobox1 (WOX1) in Arabidopsis [46, 56], MAEWEST (MAW) in petunia [56], LATHROIDES (LATH) in pea [57] and LAM1 in tobacco [55]. Among these, the classical bladeless lam1 mutant [58] exhibits the most severely affected lamina reduction phenotype while the wox1 mutant is the least affected, where functional redundancy with PRESSED FLOWER (PRS) appeared to be insulating the effects [46,56]. PRS also called WOX3 is homologue of the maize narrow sheath genes NS1 and NS2, which redundantly function in regulating maize leaf lamina expansion [59]. While lam1, maw, stf and lath mutants representing both simple and compound leaves produce narrow lamina as single mutants, the wox1 mutant appears to be an exception in requiring mutation at the prs locus to cause a similar phenotype. The reason for this phenotype difference between Arabidopsis and the other dicots has not been investigated. STF and its homologues, including WOX1, are expressed at the adaxialabaxial boundary region of the leaf primordium both in the leaf margin and in the middle mesophyll [46,55,56], and regulate lamina expansion by controlling cell proliferation [46,55]. This led to the proposal of a three-domain model (adaxial, middle, abaxial) for lamina outgrowth in Arabidopsis [60]. These findings together suggest that a WUS-like function that resides in the middle domain is required for cell proliferation-mediated lamina outgrowth. Indeed, this function can be substituted in stf and lam1 mutants by Arabidopsis WUS [55,61] indicating that STF and its homologues could establish and maintain a cell proliferation zone at the adaxial-abaxial junction during leaf morphogenesis [62].
Genetic evidence suggests that Arabidopsis WOX1 may interact with adaxial and abaxial polarity factors, AS2 and KAN1, in a mutually antagonistic manner [46] suggesting a mechanism for maintaining a cell proliferation zone protected from differentiation factors. It is therefore likely that the WOX genes in the middle keep cells in a proliferating state and supply cells for differentiation in the adaxial and abaxial domains thereby forming expanded planar lamina. In this context, AS1 and FIL whose expression is expanded into the middle domain may have additional functions independent of AS2 and KAN, respectively. For example, unlike KAN, FIL activates AS1 and WOX1 in the middle domain. Since the major players, HD-ZIP III, AS1/AS2, KAN, FIL/YAB, ARF, and WOX all encode transcriptional regulators, identifying their direct and indirect targets will enlighten our understanding. A recent progress in this area is pointing to the involvement of multiple phytohormones and sugar metabolites in the process [55,63-65], opening a window of opportunity to investigate how environmental, metabolic, and developmental signals are integrated at the dicot leaf primordium. Phylotactic arrangement of leaves, architecture of lobes and serrations at leaf margins, and leaflet placement in compound leaves appear to be modulated by the phytohormone auxin. Whether dorsoventral polaity patterning itself or the coordination of cell proliferation in the middle domain and cell differentiation in the adaxial and abaxial domains is controlled by phytohormones is yet to be established. Further studies using advanced techniques and integrated approaches in genetics, biochemical, cell biology, and metabolomics will uncover details of the network in the design and workings of the living solar panel, the lamina.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I thank Dr. Fei Zhang for interesting discussions. Research in my lab is supported in part by Oklahoma Center for the Advancement of Science and Technology Grant PBS11-002, and by National Science Foundation Grant EPS-0814361.