Diagnosis of Behçet’s Disease in Patients with Intracardiac Thrombi: A Real Big Challenge
- 1. Cardiovascular Medicine Department, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University Hospitals, Cairo, Egypt
- 2. Rheumatology and Rehabilitation Department, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University Hospitals, Cairo, Egypt
- 3. Department of Cardiology, West German Heart and Vascular Center, Essen University Hospital, Duisburg-Essen University, Essen, Germany
About the Corresponding Author
Dr. Heba Farouk
Summary of background:
Lecturer, Cardiovascular Department, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt
Current research focus:
• Adult congenital heart disease
• Echocardiography
• Cardiovascular complications in patients with Behcet's disease
Websites:
ResearchGate - https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Heba_Farouk3 Google Scholar - https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=k3y7Uy8AA AAJ&hl=en
Permanent e-mail address: Hfsaleh1@yahoo.com
Abstract
Objective: To conduct a systematic review of published case reports and case series on the management of intracardiac thrombi (ICT) in patients with Behçet’s disease (BD).
Methods: Medline, EMBASE, and Google Scholar databases were searched for case reports and case series published 2000 to 2014 reporting cases of BD complicated by ICT. Keywords included Behçet’s disease, intracardiac thrombi, and cardiac involvement in BD. Reports published in English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese were included.
Results: A total of 154 of BD complicated by ICT were published from 2000 to end of 2014. Sixty-seven cases were described in case series while 77 case reports were available for analysis. The most commonly reported clues and keywords that were mentioned in these reports to describe the clinical picture of patients with BD and ICT were dyspnea, fever, hemoptysis, right sided cardiac thrombi, associated pulmonary artery aneurysms, high incidence of pulmonary thromboembolic events, systemic venous occlusion, orogenital ulcers, elevated inflammatory markers, recurrence following surgical resection, and death due to fatal hemoptysis. Thirty-five percent of patients did not fulfill the international study group criteria for diagnosis of BD. Diagnosis was made based on the presence of orogenital ulcers with or without manifestations of other systems affection. About one third of the patients had undergone surgical resection of the ICT. The majority of these cases were not diagnosed as BD prior to the surgical intervention. The diagnosis of BD was made retrospectively based on the histopathological findings or following recurrence, and post-operative appearance of orogenital ulcerations.
Conclusion: Concerning the management of ICT in BD, it seems that establishing the diagnosis is the most challenging part of the story. The early dermatological/rheumatological consultation for all patients presenting with ICT would help in early establishment of the diagnosis and might avoid extensive -occasionally unnecessary- investigations and surgical procedures.
KEYWORDS
• Behçet’s disease
• Intracardiac thrombi
• Pulmonary artery aneurysm
• Orogenital ulcers
• Diagnosis
CITATION
Farouk H, Elsaid E, El-Chilali K (2016) Diagnosis of Behçet’s disease in patients with intracardiac thrombi: A real big challenge. Int J Rare Dis Orphan Drugs 1(1): 1001
INTRODUCTION
The diagnosis of Behçet’s disease (BD) is extensively based on clinical features due to the lack of specific laboratory and imaging findings [1]. Several diagnostic criteria have been proposed for establishing the diagnosis of BD. The sensitivity and specificity of these suggested criteria are basically different. In a previous study aiming at comparing the sensitivity and specificity of various proposed diagnostic criteria of BD, Cheng & Zhang criteria showed the highest sensitivity (100%) but also the least specificity (74.2%) for diagnosis compared to the other criteria. Hamza criteria were more sensitive and more specific for making a diagnosis (98.2% and 100%) compared to both the international study group (ISG) and Japanese criteria. Dil?en criteria were also found to be more sensitive and more specific compared to the Japanese criteria [2]. Still, ISG are the most frequently used criteria for diagnosing BD. According to the ISG criteria, the diagnosis of BD should be made based on the presence of recurrent oral ulceration (at least 3 times in one 12-month period) plus any of two other findings including recurrent genital ulceration, specific eye lesions, specific skin lesions, and a positive pathergy test. Recently and in order to increase the sensitivity of ISG criteria, a new set of diagnostic criteria has been established with the addition of both the vascular and neurological manifestations [3].
Intracardiac thrombi (ICT) in an otherwise structurally normal heart were reported in patients with BD. Occasionally, these thrombi may precede the other manifestations of the disease. Moreover, the appearance of oral ulcers (considered as an obligatory criterion in the ISG for BD diagnosis) may be detected only following the surgical resection of the thrombi [4-6]. Additionally, a group of other clinical manifestations as pulmonary artery aneurysms, pulmonary thromboembolic events, and systemic venous occlusions were commonly detected in patients with BD and ICT [5,7-9]. This systematic review analysed the data from all case reports and case series published 2000 to 2014 to describe the management of patients with BD and ICT.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Medline, EMBASE, and Google scholar databases were searched for case reports and case series published 2000 to end of 2014 reporting cases with BD complicated by ICT. Keywords included Behçet’s disease, Adamantiades-Behçet’s disease, intracardiac thrombi, intracardiac masses, right ventricular thrombi, right atrial thrombi, cardiac thrombosis, cardiac pseudotumor, and cardiac involvement in BD. Case reports published in English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese were included. Bibliographies of all available articles were reviewed for all possible relevant ones.
RESULTS
A total of 154 cases with BD complicated by ICT were published from 2000 to end 2014 [4,5,7-86]. Seventy-seven case reports with full texts [5,7,9-70] were available for further analysis (Table 1) Sixty-seven cases were described in case series. The majority of reported patients in the available case series had thrombi in the right side of the heart and associated pulmonary thromboembolic events. Patients from Sultanate Oman had associated pulmonary artery aneurysms and were treated adequately without the concomitant use of anticoagulation [76]. In one case series from China, 30% of patients did not fulfill the ISG criteria at the onset of the cardiac complication [75]. Forty-four percent of patients in the case series from France were originated mostly from North Africa. 60% of cases had evidence of pulmonary thromboembolic complications and all patients received anticoagulation. Two patients underwent surgical resection of the cardiac masses while the ICT resolved in the remaining 8 patients who received corticosteroids, azathioprine and anticoagulation [73].
Table 1: Patient characteristics, symptoms, site, and management of intracardiac thrombi in patients with Behçet’s disease
No | Study | Age | Sex | Symptoms | Site | Treatment | Outcome | Diagnostic clues |
1 | Vaya et | 16 | M | Fever, dyspnea, hemoptysis | RV, RA | Surgery, LMWH, predniso-lone, azathioprine | Recurrence after surgical removal | Orogenital ulcers, cardiovascular involve-ment |
2 | Basaran et | 28 | M | Dyspnea, fatigue, leg edema | RV, RA | Surgery, steroids, cyclospo-rine, AC | Resolution of symptoms and thrombus following surgery | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, positive pathergy test |
3 | Baykan et | 33 | M | Dyspnea, cough, hemoptysis | RV, RA | Heparin, steroids, colchicine, AC, cyclophos-phamide | Reduced mass size | Orogenital ulcers, posi-tive pathergy test |
4 | Özalti et | 27 | M | Fever, chest pain, hemop-tysis | RV | Surgery, heparin, steroids, colchicine, AC, antibiotics | Recurrence after surgical removal | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
5 | Dincer et | 39 | M | Fatigue, fever, weight loss | RA | Surgery, steroids, colchi-cine, AC, cyclosporine | Recurrence after surgical removal | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
6 | Cemri et | 27 | M | Dyspnea, hemoptysis, chest pain | RA | Steroids, AC, cyclophos-phamide | Disappeared on medical treatment | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, positive pathergy test |
7 | Houman et | 29 | M | Fever, chest pain, dyspnea, hemoptysis | RV | Surgery, steroids, colchi-cine, AC, cyclophospha-mide | Recurrence after surgical removal | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
8 | Ilvan et | 22 | M | Dyspnea, hemoptysis, chest pain, cough | RV, RA | Steroids | Recurrence | Orogenital ulcers, pulmonary aneurysms |
9 | Goktekin et | 23 | M | Hemoptysis, edema, confu-sion | RV, RA | Surgery, Steroids, cyclo-phosphamide, ampho-tericin B | Death due to hepatic failure | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
10 | Altunkeser et | 29 | F | Cough, dyspnea, palpitations | RA | Surgery, AC, aspirin | Recurrence after surgical removal | Known case of BD |
11 | Hassikou et | 38 | M | Chest pain, hemoptysis | NA | Cyclophosphamide, ste-roids, heparin, antibiotics | Death due to massive hemoptysis | Known case of BD |
12 | Gönlügür et | 35 | F | Fever, chest pain, cough, dyspnea | RV, RA | Surgery, AC | Death due to massive hemoptysis | Known case of BD |
13 | Gönlügür et | 27 | M | Cough, dyspnea | RV | Steroids, azathioprine | Both ICT and PAA disap-peared. | Orogenital ulcers, PAA, arthralgia, DVT |
14 | Kaya et | 25 | M | Fever, cough, hemoptysis | RV | Steroids, cyclophospha-mide | Good response to medi-cal treatment | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, positive pathergy test |
15 | Ben Ghorbel et | 33 | M | Hemoptysis, chest pain, fever, dyspnea | RV | Surgery, steroids, colchi-cine, AC, cyclophospha-mide | Recurrence after surgery | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
16 | Ben Ghorbel et | 29 | M | Dyspnea, heart failure | RA | Steroids, AC, colchicine | Persistence of symptoms. Patient refused surgical intervention | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, positive pathergy test |
17 | Ben Ghorbel et | 25 | M | Hemoptysis | RA | Surgery, Steroids, AC, colchicine, cyclophos-phamide, amiodarone, antibiotics | Recurrence after surgery | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, positive pathergy test |
18 | Hammami et | 20 | M | Dyspnea, cough, hemoptysis | RV, RA | LMWH, steroids, colchi-cine, AC, cyclophospha-mide | The mass disappeared | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, polyarthralgias |
19 | Hammami et | 29 | M | Fever, loss of weight, chest pain | RA | Heparin, steroids, colchicine, AC, cyclophos-phamide | The mass disappeared | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, positive pathergy test |
20 | Kaneko et | 46 | M | Fever, leg swelling, right oculomotor nerve palsy | RA | Steroids, AC, cyclophos-phamide | The mass disappeared | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
21 | Darie et | 31 | F | Fever, loss of weight | RV | Surgery, steroids, colchi-cine, AC, folic acid | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Oral ulcers, skin lesions, eye findings |
22 | Atalay et | 36 | M | Fever, hemoptysis, oral ulcer | RV | Steroids, cyclophosphamide | Death due to massive hemoptysis | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
23 | Ernam et | 20 | M | Dyspnea, hemoptysis, fever, partial loss of vision | RV | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide | The patient improved | Orogenital ulcers, eye lesion |
24 | Okumus et | 23 | F | Dyspnea, hemoptysis | RA | Steroids, LMWH, AC, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, positive HLA-B51 |
25 | Dogan et | 33 | F | Cough, fever, chest pain, hemoptysis, weight loss | RV | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Known case of BD |
26 | Kasifoglu et | 24 | M | Fever, chest pain | RA | Steroids, AC, heparin cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, vascular thrombosis |
27 | Miranda et | 14 | M | Fever, chest pain, hemoptysis, weight loss, dyspnea | RV | Surgery, steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide | The patient improved after surgery | Oral ulcers, skin lesions |
28 | Yakut et | 24 | F | Cough, dyspnea | RV, RA | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide, colchicine | Regression of the ICT | Orogenital ulcers, vascular thrombosis |
29 | Vahedian et | 17 | M | Fever, weight loss, fatigue, malaise | RV | Steroids, colchicine, AC, cyclosporine | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
30 | Kayija et | 26 | F | Fever, digital edema | RA | Surgery, steroids, colchicine, AC | Resolution of the mass | Orogenital ulcers, arthritis, positive HLA-B51 |
31 | Endo et | 13 | F | Intermittent leg pain, popliteal artery occlusion | LV, RV, RA | Surgery, urokinase, LMWH, Infliximab, cyclophosphamide | Recurrence after surgery, improved with medical treatment | Orogenital ulcers, arterial thrombosis, PA |
32 | Leibowitz et | 34 | F | Hemoptysis, dyspnea | RV | Steroids, azathioprine, cyclosporine | Complete resolution of the mass | Known case of BD |
33 | Leibowitz et | 20 | M | Scrotal ulcers, PAA | RV | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide | Complete resolution of the mass | Genital ulcers, PAA |
34 | Leibowitz et | 45 | M | Facial and neck swelling | RA | Steroids, AC | Complete resolution of the mass | SVC syndrome, ICT |
35 | Chang et | 54 | M | Dyspnea, cough, fever | RV | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide, azathiop | Initially, ICT disappeared on medical treatment but later, death due to massive hemoptysis | Known case of BD |
36 | Chiari et | 20 | M | Dyspnea, fever, hemoptysis | RV | Steroids, AC, azathioprine, heparin, antibiotics | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers |
37 | Houari et | 18 | M | Dyspnea, cough, hemoptysis, fever, chest pain | RV | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide | Regression of the ICT | Orogenital ulcers, positive pathergy test |
38 | Takahama et | 68 | M | Fever | RV | Steroids, colchicine | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, epididymitis, positive HLA-B51 |
39 | Vivante et | 14 | M | Fever, weight loss, skin rash, hemoptysis | RV | Steroids, LMWH, colchicine, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Oral ulcers, skin lesions, PAA |
40 | El Louali et | 30 | M | Dyspnea | RA | Heparin, steroids, colchicine, AC, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Known case of BD |
41 | El Louali et | 52 | M | Dyspnea | RV | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Oral ulcers, vascular lesions, positive pathergy test and HLAB51 tests |
42 | El Louali et | 23 | M | Hemoptysis | RV | Steroids, colchicine, AC, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, positive HLA-B51 |
43 | Jahdali et | 23 | F | Hemoptysis, headache | RV | Steroids, colchicine, cyclophosphamide, AC, heparin, azathioprine | Favorable response to treatment | Oral ulcerations, papilledema |
44 | Moreno et | 24 | M | Hemoptysis, chest pain, fever | RV | Surgery, steroids, colchicine, AC, azathioprine, antibiotics | Recurrence of the ICT | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
45 | Piga et | 22 | F | Right leg pain and swelling | RV | Surgery, steroids, AC, LMWH, streptokinase | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
46 | Sacre et | 49 | M | Dyspnea | LV | Steroids, colchicine, azathioprine, AC, cyclophosphamide | Regression of the ICT | Orogenital ulcers, skin and eye lesions |
47 | Adams et | 16 | M | Fever, malaise, fatigue, chest pain | RV | Surgery, steroids, AC, heparin, colchicine, methotrexate | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Oral ulcers, folliculitis, arthritis |
48 | Hiwarkar et | 22 | F | Fever, night sweats, swelling and pain in the right leg | RV | Surgery, LMWH, steroids, AC, lepirudin streptokinase | Persistence of the mass following surgery | Oral ulcers, skin lesions, extensive thrombosis |
49 | Solmaz et | 35 | M | Facial swelling | RA | Immunosuppressive therapy, AC | NA | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, vein throm-bosis |
50 | Kim et | 31 | M | Abdominal pain on walking, arthralgia | RA | Heparin, Urokinase, steroids, AC | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, arthralgia |
51 | Gopathi et | 27 | M | Dyspnea, cough, hemoptysis, weight loss, chest pain | RV | Steroids | NA | Oral ulcers, skin lesions, vascular involvement |
52 | Khammar et | 35 | F | Lower limb venous occlusion | RV RA | Steroids, AC, colchicine | Favorable response to treatment | Oral ulcers, positive pathergy test, skin lesions |
53 | Khammar et | 46 | M | Loss of weight, anemia, loss of appetite | RA | Steroids, colchicine, AC, azathioprine | Favorable response to treatment | Oral ulcers, conjunctival lesion, skin lesions |
54 | Khammar et | 40 | M | Dyspnea, abdominal pain | LV | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Oral ulcers, venous occlusion |
55 | Thamothera et | 21 | M | Blind eye, abdominal pain | RA | LMWH, AC, steroids, azathioprine | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, uveitis, positive pathergy test |
56 | Elqatni et | 30 | M | Cough, hemoptysis, night sweats | RA | Steroids, AC, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Oral ulcers, skin lesions |
57 | Yeung et | 39 | M | Night sweats, rigors, weight loss | RV | Steroids, azathioprine | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Oral ulcers, skin lesions |
58 | Hammami et | 20 | M | Fever | RV | Heparin, steroids, colchicine, AC, cyclophosphamide, interferone | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, positive HLA-B51 |
59 | Canpolat et | 32 | M | Cough, hemoptysis, sweating, loss of weight | RV | Heparin, steroids, colchicine, cyclophosphamide, AC | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
60 | Malik et | 18 | M | Fever, chest pain | RV | Surgery, steroids, azathioprine, AC | Favorable response | Scrotal ulcer, positive pathergy test, ICT |
61 | Yao et | 35 | F | Fever, dyspnea | RV | Surgery, treatment of BD as prescribed by rheumatologists | Favorable response | Known case of BD |
62 | Duzgun et | 22 | M | Fever, slurred speech, hypoesthesia on the left arm | LV | LMWH, steroids, colchicine, antibiotics, aspirin, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, cerebral, pulmonary lesions, ICT |
63 | Duzgun et | 24 | M | Fever, dyspnea | RV | Steroids, colchicine, cyclophosphamide | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Known case of BD |
64 | Duzgun et | 25 | M | Fever, abdominal pain | RA | LMWH, steroids, colchicine, antibiotics, cyclophosphamide | The mass reduced in size | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
65 | A?ker et | 20 | F | Cough, fever, palpitations, chest pain | RV | LMWH, steroids, cyclophosphamide | Partial resolution of the ICT | Known case of BD |
66 | Ghori et | 19 | M | Fever, weight loss | RV | Surgery, heparin, AC, steroids, azathioprine | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, indurations at venipuncture sites |
67 | El Euch et | 33 | M | Fever, chest pain, weight loss | LV | Surgery, steroids, colchicine, AC, antibioti | Clinical improvement | Orogenital ulcers, neurological lesions, ICT |
68 | Neves et | 38 | M | Chest pain, fever, cough, dyspnea, hemoptysis | RV | AC, steroids | Clinical improvement | Oral ulcers, skin lesions, positive pathergy test |
69 | Bouzelmat et | 26 | M | Hemoptysis, dyspnea, loss of weight | RA | Steroids, cyclophosphamide, AC | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions |
70 | Aksu et | 29 | M | Dyspnea, palpitations, chest pain | RA | Heparin, steroids, colchicine, cyclophosphamid | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Known case of BD |
71 | Dimitrios et | 32 | M | Dizziness, headache, dyspnea, fever | RA | Surgery, LMWH, AC, aspirin, azathioprine, steroids, colchicine, folic acid | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Orogenital ulcers, positive HLA-B51, positive pathergy test, eye lesions |
72 | Xing et | 43 | F | Fever, cough, dyspnea, chest discomfort | RV | AC, antibiotics | The mass reduced in size | Known case of BD |
73 | Leibowitz et | 35 | M | Fever, night sweats, headache | RV | Surgery, steroids, antibiotics, AC, azathioprine | Recurrence after surgical resection | Oral ulcers |
74 | Leibowitz et | 9 | M | Fever, oral ulcers | RV | Surgery, steroids | Disappearance of the cardiac thrombus | Oral ulcers, recurrent thrombophlebitis |
75 | Aksu et | 33 | M | Dyspnea, fatigue, weight loss | RV | Surgery, steroids, AC, colchicine | Recurrence after surgery | Recurrent ICT, oral ulcers, possible BD |
76 | Madureira et | 14 | M | Fever, chest pain, oral ulcer | RV | Surgery, steroids, antibiotics, cyclophosphamide | Favorable response | Orogenital ulcers, skin lesions, positive HLA-B51 |
77 | Ozcan et | 26 | M | Cough, dyspnea, hemoptysis, weight loss | RV | Steroids, cyclophosphamide, azathioprine, colchicine | Favorable response | Known case of BD |
Abbreviations: AC: anticoagulation; BD: Behçet’s disease; ICT: intracardiac thrombus; F: female; LMWH: low molecular weight heparin; M: male; PAA: pulmonary artery aneurysm; RA: right atrium; RV: right ventricle; LV: left ventricle |
Seventy-six percent of case reports were from the Mediterranean basin (n=59 patients), 27 patients (44%) were from Turkey, 17 from North Africa (29%), and 9 from Southern Europe (15%). Mean age of patients was 28.7±10 years. The youngest case (9 years) was from the Mediterranean basin while the oldest was from Japan (68 years). Fifteen patients were females (19%). The overall male to female ratio is 4:1 but higher in patients from Mediterranean basin (5.5:1). Forty percent of females were diagnosed as BD prior to the development of ICT, on the other hand, only 11% of males were previously known cases of BD although the mean age of both males and females was comparable (29±11 versus 28±8, p= 0.6). Only 13 patients were diagnosed as BD before the appearance of the ICT. The treatment was mentioned in only 5 cases, 2 were on both corticosteroids and colchicine, two were non-compliant to colchicine therapy, and the last one was on irregular corticosteroid therapy.
The most commonly reported symptoms were fever, shortness of breath, hemoptysis, chest pain, weight loss, and cough (52%, 43%, 38%, 29%, 23%, and 22% respectively). Other less frequently mentioned symptoms included palpitations, fatigue, edema, and abdominal complaints. Mean duration of symptoms was 81±95 days (range: 1 to 500). Nineteen patients (25%) had previous thrombotic events affecting the veins of the lower limbs (n=10), the cerebral veins (n=4), the heart (n=3), and the inferior vena cava (n=2).
Thirty-four patients (44%) had skin lesions, the majority were in the form of papulopustular eruption and pseudofolliculitis. Examination of the eye was mentioned in only 27 patients, 52% of them (n=14) showed no abnormalities. Pathergy test was available in only 37 reports being positive in 61% (n=21). A summary of the laboratory investigations is shown in Table 2.
Table 2: Laboratory findings in patients with BD
Laboratory findings | Value |
Hemoglobin, gm/dl | 10±1.7 |
White blood count | 11.7±5 |
Erythrocyte sedimentation rate | 78±36 |
C- reactive protein | 76±81 |
Abnormal coagulation profile | 5/41 (12%) |
Positive HLA-B51 | 21/27 (88%) |
Abnormal anti-nuclear/anti DNA tests | 6/49 (12%) |
Data is expressed as mean ± standard deviation, numbers, and percentages |
The interpretation of chest X-ray was available in 46 cases, being abnormal in 33 patients (71%). The most commonly detected abnormalities were pulmonary opacities/consolidation (n=15), hilar enlargement (n=12), and pleural effusion (n=3). Computed tomography (CT) data were available in 70 patients. Pulmonary thromboembolism, pulmonary aneurysms, intracardiac thrombi, and systemic venous obstruction were the most commonly reported CT findings. Abnormal CT brain findings were detected in 3 patients. Systemic venous thrombosis was documented in 35 patients while only 7 patients had concomitant arterial lesions. Pulmonary thromboembolism was diagnosed using chest CT, lung perfusion scintigraphy, magnetic resonance imaging, and pulmonary angiography in two-thirds of patients.
Thirteen patients were previously diagnosed as BD. The criteria used for diagnosis of BD in the remaining 64 patients were as follows: thirteen patients (20%) had evident oral -with or without genital ulcerations- and 2 other major criteria (skin, eye lesions, or positive pathergy test). Twenty-four patients (37%) had orogenital ulcers and skin lesions, 3 (5%) had orogenital ulcers and a positive pathergy test, and only one patient was diagnosed based on the presence of ulcers and eye manifestations. The remaining 23 patients (35%) did not fulfill the ISG criteria for diagnosis of BD. Diagnosis was made based on the presence of orogenital ulcers with manifestations of other systems affection as the cardiovascular and neurological systems. The suspicion of BD was made postoperatively based on the histopathological findings from surgically resected ICT (organized thrombus with or without associated inflammatory infiltration, and occasionally evidence of endomyocardial fibrosis), the recurrence of ICT, or the appearance of oral or scrotal ulcers following surgery.
Seven patients had abnormal left ventricular findings by echocardiography (thrombi in 5 patients and impaired overall systolic function in 2). 60% of left ventricular thrombi (n=3) were complicated by systemic embolization (cerebral vessels=2, popliteal artery=1). Pulmonary thromboembolism was detected in only one patient with isolated left ventricular thrombus. Isolated right ventricular thrombi were detected in 41 cases. About 75% of them had concomitant pulmonary embolism. Twenty-one patients had right atrial thrombi (60% had pulmonary thromboembolism) while 9 patients had thrombi in both right atrial and ventricular chambers (88% of them had pulmonary thromboembolism). The intracardiac thrombi were mobile in 22 cases, 81% of these mobile thrombi were associated with pulmonary thromboembolism.
The most commonly prescribed drugs in addition to corticosteroids were anticoagulants (n=64), cyclophosphamide (n=40), colchicine (n=33), and azathioprine. Three patients died while on medical treatment. The cause of death (2 of them were on anticoagulants) was massive hemoptysis. 35% of patients had undergone surgical resection of the ICT. The majority of these cases were not diagnosed as BD prior to the surgical intervention and diagnosis was made retrospectively based on the histopathological findings or following recurrence of the ICT, or the post-operative appearance of orogenital ulcerations. Following surgery, two patients died. One from massive hemoptysis developed 6 months later and the other from acute hepatic failure.
DISCUSSION
This systematic review showed that patients with BD and ICT had a worse prognosis. Five out of the 77 cases died with severe hemoptysis being the cause of death in 4 patients. This indicated that concomitant pulmonary aneurysms, rather than the ICT, are responsible for such high mortality [6]. The majority of patients with BD presented initially with ICT in this review had associated abnormalities in the form of pulmonary lesions (aneurysms, thromboembolism), venous obstruction (veins of the lower limbs, cerebral veins, superior and inferior vena cava), and elevated inflammatory markers. Occasionally, a positive HLA-B51 was detected and was used in the presence of orogenital ulcerations as a criterion for diagnosis of BD [35]. According to a previous systematic review, the frequency of pulmonary involvement in patients with BD and ICT is much higher than in those without ICT [6]. A possible concomitant endothelial/subendothelial injury involving both the heart and pulmonary arterial bed was suggested [21].
The most important challenge that faced physicians in many of the present reports was the diagnosis rather than the treatment of the disease. The diagnosis of BD based on some of these reports seems to be very difficult and required many – sometimes even unnecessary- investigations. We believe that 2 important causes might be the source of such difficulties. The first is the fact that the majority of patients with ICT and not previously known to have BD complained initially of shortness of breath, cough, hemoptysis, and fever so they were commonly referred to either a cardiologist, or a cardiothoracic surgeon rather than a specialist (rheumatologist/dermatologist) for further evaluation. Cardiologists/cardiothoracic surgeons may not consider the diagnosis of BD in these patients because the presence of ICT and associated pulmonary lesions could explain the patient’s symptoms. Additionally, asking routinely about orogenital ulcers, and examination of the eye and skin to elicit the criteria of the disease (which was not considered in the differential diagnosis) do not belong to the daily patients’ assessment in the cardiac/ cardiothoracic surgical wards. The early referral of all patients with ICT to a rheumatologist/dermatologist, even in the absence of the manifestations of BD, could help and support the diagnosis of BD as early as possible [87].
The second source of difficulty in making the diagnosis of BD in patients with ICT is that the proposed ISG criteria for diagnosis of BD were not met in all the reported cases [5,41,43,48,60,63,75]. Orogenital ulcers occurred in some patients during their hospital stay or following the post-operative resection of the mass [4,5,10,13,46,58]. Moreover, some patients were not diagnosed as BD based on the proposed widely known and used ISG criteria for BD diagnosis [48,63]. Some were diagnosed based on the presence of orogenital ulcers and cardiovascular involvement, [13,29,60] the presence of orogenital ulcers and positive HLA-B51 tests, [41,43] or the orogenital ulcers, neurological, and cardiovascular involvement [20,63]. Furthermore, two reports have considered oral ulceration of less than 1-year duration as a criterion for diagnosis of BD [40,63].
In order to improve the clinical sensitivity of the ISG criteria, a new set of diagnostic criteria was proposed [3]. Recently, both vascular and neurological complications were added to the original ISG criteria for diagnosis of BD based on studying 2556 patients collected from 27 countries [88]. The role of ICT was not unfortunately mentioned. Whether to consider ICT as a vascular manifestation is not clear. Furthermore, we do not know exactly how to calculate the score in patients with more than one vascular lesions; for example, in patients with both pulmonary aneurysms and deep vein thrombosis. Also, it is not stated whether to include previous thrombotic events as superficial thrombophlebitis, ICT, pulmonary embolism in the criteria for diagnosis. Addition of the ICT, especially when combined with pulmonary aneurysms, to the criteria for diagnosis of BD might alleviate this diagnostic challenge. We found 154 cases of ICT and BD published 2000 to end of 2014, additional 25 cases (1965 to 2000) were also studied in a previous report, so there are currently in the literature more than 179 cases of BD and ICT. Analysis of the data of this subgroup of patients could provide a lot of missed information.
Embolic events in BD
This review showed that 60% of patients with BD complicated by left ventricular thrombi suffered from an embolic event. The first patient (22-year-old) presented to the emergency ward with fever and neurological symptoms (hypoesthesia and slurred speech). Neurological examination revealed right facial paralysis and dysarthria. Brain imaging showed multiple acute infarcts in the right frontal, parietal, temporal, and occipital regions. Diagnosis of BD was made based on history of recurrent orogenital ulcers, cerebral, and cardiovascular involvement. Three months later and while on immunosuppressive therapy, the left ventricular thrombus disappeared and the neurological examination was unremarkable [60]. The second patient (33-year-old Tunisian) complained of shortness of breath, fever, headache, and right hemiparesis. The CT scan showed evidence of left occipitoparietal embolic lesion. The patient was operated and diagnosis of BD was made based on the presence of orogenital ulcers, neurological, and intracardiac thrombosis [63]. The third patient (13-year-old girl) had acute popliteal artery embolic occlusion and left ventricular mass. She underwent surgical removal of the left ventricular thrombus while multiple masses were additionally detected in the right ventricle, atria, and coronary sinus. The patient had additionally pulmonary aneurysm and was diagnosed as BD based on history of intermittent ulcers, pulmonary aneurysms, and cardiovascular thrombosis [36]. On the other hand, 98% of pulmonary thromboembolic events were recorded in patients with right sided thrombi. So, it seems that both the ICT and pulmonary thromboembolic events are somehow related to each other. It was previously suggested that pulmonary vascular lesions in BD are due to in-situ vasculitis rather than due to embolization whether from the heart or from the peripheral veins because the thrombi are usually tightly adherent to the underlying endothelial lining [6]. Only 25 reports commented on the mobility of the cardiac masses. 22 were mobile and 88% of them were associated with pulmonary thromboembolic findings. This particular finding should be further studied because it has important therapeutic impact. Few physicians in these reports avoided anticoagulation in patients with ICT because of fear of rupture of pulmonary aneurysm with subsequent hemoptysis and hemorrhage, the majority, however, prescribed anticoagulation (n=64). About 85% of these patients improved with the use of anticoagulation while 2 patients developed severe fatal hemoptysis [20,21,38]. Interestingly, an ICT reduced in size in a patient who received only anticoagulation without concomitant use of immunosuppressive therapy [67]. We could not ignore the mortality seen in patients receiving anticoagulation, but also we could not deny its beneficial therapeutic effect in the remaining patients. The use of anticoagulation in patients with ICT should be based on analysis of all available reports and case series to create a score system providing better choice of patients who should not receive anticoagulants without depriving the others from their therapeutic benefit.
As previously mentioned [6], the differential diagnosis of ICT was a primary cardiac tumor especially myxoma and vegetations of infective endocarditis. The clinical picture in some reports, however, simulated other diseases as tuberculosis [18], respiratory tract infection [45], myeloproliferative disease [51], other rheumatological disease, malignancies [48], and fever of unknown origin [41].
CONCLUSION
The diagnosis of BD in patients presenting with ICT is a challenging task especially for cardiologists. The early dermatological/rheumatological consultation for all patients with ICT is therefore recommended. Addition of ICT, especially when combined with pulmonary artery aneurysms, to the criteria used for diagnosis of BD might increase its sensitivity and allow earlier diagnosis of the disease. Some ICT are mobile and might be responsible for the development of pulmonary and peripheral embolic complications. The use of anticoagulation in patients with BD and ICT should be based on clear recommendations.
DISCLOSURE
The authors declare no conflicts of interst.
REFERENCES