Genetic Perspective of Corneal Endothelial Dystrophies
- 1. Department of Genetics, Dr G Venkataswamy Eye Research Institute, India
- 2. Cornea and Refractive Surgeries, Aravind Eye Hospital, India
Abstract
The corneal endothelium serves primarily in maintaining stromal deturgescence which is essential for transparency of cornea. Any disturbance in its function leads to stromal edema which in turn reduces vision. The genetically heterogeneous nature of four different kinds of corneal endothelial dystrophies represents the involvement of diverse set of genes. Until now, only few genes were identified for a subclass of corneal endothelial dystrophy. Therefore, in this review, elucidated genes and their function involved in different corneal endothelial dystrophies were described to understand the pathogenesis of the disorder.
Keywords
• Corneal endothelial dystrophy
• Mutations
• X-linked inheritence
Citation
Hemadevi B, Prajna NV, Srinivasan M, Sundaresan P (2017) Genetic Perspective of Corneal Endothelial Dystrophies. JSM Genet Genomics 4(2): 1026.
INTRODUCTION
Corneal dystrophies are defined as primary, inherited, bilateral disorders affecting corneal transparency and refraction, leading to varying degrees of visual disturbances. They are generally said to be of early onset, axial, symmetric, slowly progressive, free from vascularization, and not associated with other systemic conditions. The dystrophies have been traditionally classified according to the layer of involvement into anterior membrane dystrophies (epithelium, epithelial basement membrane, and Bowman layer dystrophies), stromal dystrophies, and endothelial dystrophies (endothelium and Descemet’s membrane (DM)). Corneal endothelial dystrophies include congenital hereditary endothelial dystrophy (CHED; MIM# 217700), Fuchs endothelial corneal dystrophy (FECD; MIM# 613267 and 610158), posterior polymorphous dystrophy (PPCD; MIM# 122000), and X- linked endothelial corneal dystrophy (XECD; MIM# 300779). These endothelial dystrophies share many features including, corneal decompensation, altered morphology of endothelial cell, and secretion of an abnormal posterior collagenous layer in the posterior zone of Descemet’s membrane, the endothelial basement membrane. Genetics underlying these diseases are being studied, although clinically distinct, corneal endothelial dystrophies share clinical features suggesting that genes implicated in one corneal dystrophy may also harbor mutations liable for other dystrophies (Table 1).
Table 1: Genetic/allelic heterogeneity of corneal endothelial dystrophies.
Corneal dystrophy | Inheritance | Locus | Location | Gene | Reference | MIM* |
Congenital hereditary endothelial dystrophy (CHED) | AD | CHED1 | 20p11-q11 | Not known | Toma et al., 1995 | 121 700 |
AR | CHED2 | 20p13-p12 | SLC4A11 | Hand et al., 1999; Vithana et al., 2006 |
217 700 | |
Fuchs endothelial corneal dystrophy (FECD) | AD | FECD1 | 1p34.3–p32.3 | COL8A2 | Biswas et al., 2001; Kobayashi et al., 2004 |
136 800 |
AD | FECD2 | 13pter– q12.13 | Not known | Sundin et al., 2006 | 610 158 | |
AD | FECD3 | 18q21.2–q21.3 | TCF4 | Baratz et al., 2010 | 613 267 | |
AD | ? | 18q12–q21 | LOXHD1 | Riazuddin et al., 2012 | 613 072 | |
Complex | FECD4 | 20p13–p12 | SLC4A11 | Riazuddin et al., 2010 | 613 268 | |
AD | FECD5 | 5q33.1–q35.2 | unknown | Riazuddin et al., 2009 | 613 269 | |
AD | FECD6 | 10p11.2 | ZEB1 | Riazuddin et al., 2010 | 613 270 | |
AD | FECD7 | 9p24.1–p22.1 | unknown | Riazuddin et al., 2010 | 613 271 | |
Complex | FECD8 | 15q25.3 | AGBL1 | Riazuddin et al., 2013 | 615 523 | |
AD | SVD | 2q37.1 | KCNJ13 | Hejtmancik et al., 2008 | 193 230 | |
Posterior polymorphous corneal dystrophy (PPCD) | AD | PPCD | 20p12.1-20p11.23 | unknown | Liskova et al., 2012 | 122 000 |
AD | PPCD1 | 20p11.2 | VSX1 | Heon et al., 2002 | 1220 000 | |
AD | PPCD2 | 1p34.3–p32.3 | COL8A2 | Biswas et al., 2001 | 609 140 | |
AD | PPCD3 | 10p11.2 | ZEB1 | Krafchak et al., 2005 | 609 141 | |
Other | 2q36–q37 | COL4A3 | Krafchak et al., 2005 | 120 070 | ||
X-linked endothelial dystrophy (XECD) | X-linked | XECD | Xq25 | Not known | Schmid et al., 2006 | 3009 |
*MIM - Mendelian inheritance in man AGBL1 - ATP/GTP-Binding protein –Like1; COL4A3 - collagen, type IV, alpha 3; COL8A2, collagen, type VIII, alpha 2; KCNJ13 - potassium inwardly rectifying channel, subfamily J, member 13; LOXHD1 - lipoxygenase homology domains 1; SLC4A11 - solute carrier family 4, sodium borate transporter, member 11; SVD - snowflake vitreoretinal degeneration; TCF4 - transcription factor 4; VSX1 - visual system homeobox 1; ZEB1 - zinc finger E-box binding homeodomain 1. |
This review focuses on the current knowledge of the genetics of corneal endothelial dystrophies.
CONGENITAL HEREDITARY ENDOTHELIAL DYSTROPHY (CHED)
CHED manifests as bilateral, symmetric, noninflammatory corneal clouding involving degeneration of the corneal endothelium without other anterior segment abnormalities, usually evident at birth or in the early postnatal period. It is characterized by diffuse ground glass opacification of the cornea, markedly thickened cornea due to edema, and a thickened DM. CHED has both autosomal dominant (CHED1; OMIM# 121700) as well as autosomal recessive (CHED2; OMIM# 217700) modes of transmission the latter more severe and usually more common. The only difference between clinical features of the dominant and recessive forms of CHED is that the recessive form may manifest earlier and is associated with nystagmus [1]. However, a careful examination of the literature indicated that CHED1 is not sufficiently distinguishable from PPCD1 to consider it a separate corneal endothelial dystrophy [2].
Hand and coworkers localized CHED2 to the short arm of chromosome 20 at 20p13 by homozygosity mapping [3]. Mutations in the sodium bicarbonate transporter-like solute carrier family 4 member 11 (SLC4A11, MIM610206) gene present in this locus were found to cause CHED2 [4]. Since the first description of SLC4A11 mutations, several case reports and small case series have been published [5-17].
The SLC4A11 gene belongs to a super family of bicarbonate transporters. The gene has 19 exons spanning 11, 774 bp of genomic DNA, which codes for a protein of 891 amino acids with a calculated molecular mass of 100 kDa. The SLC4A11 protein has 13 transmembrane domains and intracellular N and C termini. It contains multiple intracellular phosphorylation sites and 2 extracellular N-glycosylation sites [18]. SLC4A11 is also known as BTR1 (bicarbonate transporter related protein-1) or NaBC1 (sodium-coupled borate co-transporter).
Expression of BTR1/SLC4A11 gene is seen in several organs and tissues, including the eye, blood, lung, ovary, colon, mouth, embryonic tissue, pancreas, kidney, skin, cranial nerve, ascites, prostate, and brain. Vithana and coworkers by in situhybridization showed its expression in the mouse cornea at embryonic day 8, which is equivalent to human gestational month 5, the time at which CHED2 pathology develops in humans [4]. BTR1 is homologous to BOR1, a borate transporter in plants [18]. It functions as a ubiquitous electrogenic sodium-coupled borate transporter in the presence of borate, while in the absence of borate it conducts Na+ and H+ . In view of the requirement for borate in growth and development, BTR1 may be a mediator for these processes [19]. It is shown that SLC4A11 prevents severe morphological changes of the cornea caused by increased sodium chloride concentrations in the stroma [20]. However it is established that in corneal endothelium SLC4A11 acts as a Na+ - dependent pHi modulator transporting OH- with no significant affinity to B(OH)4- or HCO3- anions [21]. SLC4A11 also facilitates water movement at a rate similar to AQP proteins and corneal fluid accumulation found in genetic diseases of SLC4A11 arises at least in part from defective water movement by SLC4A11 [22].
Mutations in SLC4A11 have also been described in Harboyan syndrome (corneal dystrophy with perceptive deafness; CDPD) which is characterized phenotypically as CHED2 with sensorineural hearing loss appearing in about the second decade of life [6]. The SlC4A11 knockout model by [23] had a more pronounced phenotype in the ear (i.e., sensorineural deafness) similar to Harboyan syndrome while there were no phenotypic changes in the cornea. However SlC4A11 KO mouse model by [20] revealed morphological alterations in all layers of the cornea of 12-month-old mice. SLC4A11 KO mouse model by [24] also successfully represented clinical manifestations of human CHED as well as renal abnormalities. An in vitro study revealed that SLC4A11 knockdown in human corneal endothelial cells led to suppressed cell growth and reduced cell viability by activating the apoptotic pathway [25].
To date 76 mutations in 17 of the 19 coding exons of SLC4A11 have been identified indicating the high degree of allelic heterogeneity. Among the 76 mutations 74 are listed in publication by Kodaganur et al. [15], and rest two are in Park et al. [16], & Siddiqui et al. [17], publications. Although 32 of the 136 pedigrees screened to date do not demonstrate coding region mutations in SLC4A11 [7, 10-12, 14]. Screening of the putative SLC4A11 promoter region in 20 of these 32 families failed to demonstrate any presumed pathogenic variants [12,14]. Thus, it is possible that locus heterogeneity exists for CHED2.
FUCHS ENDOTHELIAL CORNEAL DYSTROPHY (FECD)
FECD is an adult-onset corneal disorder, which begins at 5th decade. It is a commonly occurring, progressive, bilateral, but often asymmetric, corneal dystrophy. It is characterized by the presence of guttae, which are excrescences in the Descemet’s membrane described as a ‘focal, refractile accumulation of collagen posterior to the DM [26]. In later stages of the disease, corneal edema develops due to degeneration of the corneal endothelium, with consequent loss of vision. The prevalence of FECD varies markedly across the world. It affects ~4% of the USA population over the age of 40 years [27] but is less frequent in Asian [28], and Middle-Eastern populations [29]. In Australia, corneal grafting for FECD accounts for ~6% of all corneal grafts performed annually [30].
FECD is a genetically heterogeneous disease. There are two forms defined by the age of onset. Early-onset FECD is rare [31] and is typically inherited as an autosomal dominant disease with high penetrance and almost uniform expressivity [32]. The more common late-onset FECD can either be familial or sporadic, with onset typically after the age of 40 years [33]. The risk of developing the late-onset form increases with age and female sex. Familial late onset FECD shows an autosomal dominant inheritance with high penetrance, but variable expressivity [27].
FECD loci identified by genetic linkage analysis, Genome wide association studies (GWAS), Next generation sequencing & causative genes are shown in Table 1. Linkage analysis of early onset form of FECD identified a 6-7 cM interval on chromosome 1p34.3-p32. Screening of COL8A2 (collagen, type VIII, alpha 2) gene in this interval revealed a missense mutation p.Q455K [31]. COL8A2 is an extracellular matrix protein and is a major component of DM [34]. Similarly, Gottsch et al., identified a novel point mutation in the COL8A2 gene with p.L450W substitution [35]. In addition, Mok et al., also identified the p.Q455V mutation in COL8A2 in Korean Patients with FECD [36]. However COL8A2 mutations do not play a role in the phenotypically distinct late onset form of FECD [35].
Mutations in the ZEB1 (zinc-finger E-box binding homoebox 1) gene also known as TCF8 can cause both sporadic and familial late-onset FECD [37,38]. ZEB1 is expressed in the corneal endothelium [39]. It regulates cell proliferation and differentiation by inducing epithelial– mesenchymal transition [40]. Mehta and colleagues screened ZEB1 in 74 FECD probands including 8 familial and 66 sporadic cases and found two coding region variants one of which was a synonymous substitution and a novel variant, p.N696S. Riazuddin and colleagues reported five presumed causative ZEB1 missense mutations in 7 of 384 unrelated individuals with FECD. Three of these mutations (p.Q810P, p.Q840P and p.A905T) occurred at sites that are highly evolutionarily conserved in vertebrates, while the remaining two occur at moderately conserved sites.
The SLC4A11 (solute carrier family 4, sodium borate transporter, member 11) mutations cause sporadic and familial late-onset FECD [41, 42]. Vithana et al., showed that heterozygous mutation in SLC4A11 is associated with late-onset FECD by analyzing 89 unrelated patients of Chinese and Indian decent [41]. Approximately 5% of FECD in Chinese patients and 4% of FECD in Indian patients attributed to mutations in the SLC4A11 gene. Four previously unreported mutations were identified, p.S33SfsX18 in a Chinese sporadic case, p.E399K in an Indian sporadic case, p.G709E in a Chinese familial case, and p.T754M in a Chinese sporadic case. The mutations in CHED were inherited in an autosomal recessive fashion [4], the alleles that caused FECD acted in an autosomal dominant pattern [41]. Additional mutations were identified in an American cohort by Riazuddin et al., after sequencing all coding regions of SLC4A11 in 192 FECD cases [42]. Sorting Intolerant From Tolerant (SIFT) and PolyPhen predicted that among the seven missense mutations p.E167D, p.R282P, p.Y526C, p.V575M, p.G583D, p.G742R and p.G834S identified five of the mutations were pathogenic; p.E176D and p.Y526C were predicted to be benign.
Single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the TCF4 (transcription factor 4) gene, encoding the E2-2 protein, were reported to be significantly associated with late-onset FECD in Caucasian Americans [43]. Independent replication studies have confirmed association of TCF4 variants with FECD [44-46]. In particular, the TGC trinucleotide repeat expansion (rs613872) in TCF4 is strongly associated with FECD and a repeat length >50 are highly specific for the disease [47] and a predictor of disease risk. Further studies have strengthened the association of TCF4 polymorphisms in the FECD disease process [48,49] and also suggest a role for clusterin and TGFBI polymorphisms [49]. A mutation R162W in the gene potassium inwardly-rectifying channel, subfamily J, member 13 (KCNJ13) is described in one family with snowflake vitreoretinal degeneration in which FECD was part of the ocular phenotype [50].
Next-generation sequencing of a FECD family identified a missense mutation, p.R547C in the lipoxygenase homology domains 1 (LOXHD1) gene [51]. LOXHD1 is an evolutionarily conserved protein predicted to consist of 15 PLAT (polycystin-1, lipoxygenase, alpha-toxin) domains. The biological function of PLAT domains is not well established, but it is predicted that they target proteins to the plasma membrane [52]. A further cohort of over 200 sporadic FECD patients were sequenced, and a further 15 missense changes identified in this gene [51].
Next-generation sequencing also identified a nonsense mutation (p.R1028*) in AGBL1 (ATP/GTP-Binding protein – Like1) in the 15q locus [53]. Further sequencing identified a heterozygous missense variant, c.2969G>C that results in nonconserved amino acid substitution (p.C990S). AGBL1 encodes a glutamate decarboxylase previously identified in serial analysis of gene expression of corneal endothelium, a finding confirmed by immunohistochemical staining [54].
The c.-61G>T (rs1801321) and c.-98G> C (rs1801320) polymorphisms of the RAD51 gene have a role in the FECD pathogenesis [55]. The RAD51 protein is the central protein involved in homologous recombination and repair of DNA single and double strand breaks (DSBs) in humans [56].
POSTERIOR POLYMORPHOUS CORNEAL DYSTROPHY (PPCD)
PPCD is an autosomal dominant, uncommon, inherited corneal dystrophy which shares some similarities with CHED1. It is characterized by the presence of abnormal corneal endothelial cells which display epithelial features including microvilli and inappropriate cytokeratin expression [57-59]. The age at onset of symptoms is variable and may be in early childhood in severe cases or in adulthood. Clinical outcomes vary from minimal visual impairment to an aggressive course, with development of retrocorneal membranes and corneal opacification requiring keratoplasty [60,61].
PPCD has been associated with a number of other ocular disorders, including primary open angle and secondary angleclosure glaucoma [62], as well as non-keratoconic corneal steepening [63] and keratoconus [64,65]. A number of associated extraocular manifestations, including abdominal hernia and hydrocele formation, distinguish PPCD from the majority of the other corneal dystrophies, which are traditionally considered isolated corneal disorders [66, 67].
To date three genes have been identified as causing PPCD (Table 1). Haplotype analysis in the Czech population points to an as yet unidentified gene at the PPCD1 locus [68]. A locus for PPCD (PPCD1) has been identified in the pericentromeric region of chromosome 20 through linkage analysis [69-71]. Mutation of the visual system homeobox gene 1 (VSX1) within this locus was reported as disease-causing in a few PPCD cases [72,73] but this was not replicated in other studies [70,74]. The PPCD1 locus was further reduced to 2.4 cM [75] and subsequently probed with Sanger and next-generation sequencing [76]. The underlying genetic cause within this locus appears to remain elusive. Liskova et al., further explored this locus demonstrating a founder haplotype in the Czech population, but no causative mutation was identified [68]. However recently in the VSX1 gene a novel change c.173C>T (p.P58L) was found in a patient with PPCD, predicted to be pathogenic, and not seen in 200 ethnically matched control alleles [77].
PPCD2 is caused by mutation of the alpha-2 chain of type VIII collagen gene located on 1p34.3-p32.3. Biswas et al., identified mutations in this gene in two affected members of a single PPCD family [31]. In addition a carrier of L450W mutation in COL8A2 in an early-onset FECD family was reported to have a phenotype of PPCD [35]. The involvement of COL8A2 in PPCD has not been substantiated further since no pathogenic mutations were found in additional families screened for mutations [78,79] suggesting this association is questionable or of a low frequency.
The largest percentage of PPCD (approximately one third) is associated with mutations in ZEB1, at the PPCD3 locus [67]. Aldave et al., confirmed the role of ZEB1 in PPCD3 by reporting eight additional frameshift mutations in 32 probands [66]. A study by Liskova et al., also identified ZEB1 mutations in four out of 10 PPCD families [80]. Further studies increased the number of ZEB1 mutations associated with PPCD to 24 [81-83].
ZEB1 binds to DNA at a conserved sequence (CACCTG) that is known as an E2 box. In the presence of a truncating mutation in ZEB1, COL4A3 expression has been demonstrated in the corneal endothelium of an individual affected with PPCD3 [67]. These findings, and the identification of six E2 boxes in the 5 kb upstream of the COL4A3 transcription initiation site, suggest that ZEB1 participates in the negative regulation of COL4A3 transcription. Yellore and colleagues tested this hypothesis and found that when ZEB1 is mutated, there is alteration of either the amount of expression or the temporal expression of the COL4A3 protein. This in turn may influence the endothelial cell to manifest a different phenotype [84].
X-LINKED CORNEAL ENDOTHELIAL DYSTROPHY
X-linked endothelial dystrophy remains the least common of the corneal endothelial dystrophies, reported in only a single family to date [85]. In a 7-generation Austrian family 35 trait carriers were identified in 4 generations. Twenty-two female and 13 male patients demonstrated a wide range of phenotypic features, ranging from ‘moon-crater like’ changes in the endothelium to congenital corneal edema with variable presence of visual loss ranging from no change in visual acuity to moderate or severe loss of vision. No male-to-male transmission was observed. Given apparent X-linked inheritance pattern, linkage analysis was performed for the X-chromosome, revealing evidence of significant linkage to a 14.79Mb region on Xq25 between markers DXS8057 and DXS1047, although the genetic basis remains unknown [85].
Taken together, studying the various corneal dystrophies and their pathways might be more complex because of genetic heterogeneity. Therefore, bridging the gaps using the highthroughput technique such as next generation sequencing (NGS) helps to identify and unravel the disease causing novel genes. Consequently, understanding the genetics of corneal dystrophies is essential which can provide insights into the various pathways involved in its molecular mechanisms.
REFERENCES
32. Klintworth GK. Corneal dystrophies. Orphanet J Rare Dis. 2009; 4: 7.
44. Li YJ, Minear MA, Rimmler J, Zhao B, Balajonda E, Hauser MA, et al. Replication of TCF4 through association and linkage studies in lateonset Fuchs endothelial corneal dystrophy. PLoS One. 2011; 6: 18044.
56. Sonoda E, Sasaki MS, Buerstedde JM, Bezzubova O, Shinohara A, Ogawa H, et al. Rad51-deficient vertebrate cells accumulate chromosomal breaks prior to cell death. EMBO J. 1998; 17: 598-608.
57. Cockerham GC, Laver NV, Hidayat AA, Mc Coy DL. An immunohistochemical analysis and comparison of posterior polymorphous dystrophy with congenital hereditary endothelial dystrophy. Cornea. 2002; 21: 787-791.
72. Héon E, Greenberg A, Kopp KK, Rootman D, Vincent AL, Billingsley G, et al. VSX1: a gene for posterior polymorphous dystrophy and keratoconus. Hum Mol Genet. 2002; 11: 1029-1036.
84. Yellore VS, Rayner SA, Nguyen CK, Gangalum RK, Jing Z, Bhat SP, et al. Analysis of the role of ZEB1 in the pathogenesis of posterior polymorphous corneal dystrophy. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2012; 53: 273-278.