Fusarium verticillioides, a Globally Important Pathogen of Agriculture and Livestock: A Review
- 1. Department of Studies in Microbiology, University of Mysore, India
Abstract
Fusarium verticillioides is a multi-phytopathogenic fungi widely distributed throughout the world in association with cereals and cereal based food products. Cereals are the basic staple food which provides much of the energy and protein for many populations, where 2534MT consumed as food by Humans and animals. In some developing nations, grain in the form of rice, wheat or maize constitutes a majority of daily substance. In developed nations, cereal consumption is more moderate and varied as using cereal based products like corn flakes, oats, Poultry and animal feeds etc. Due to poor agricultural practices and intermittent rain at the time of harvest cereals are prone to contamination by number of fungi and it has become unavoidable and a worldwide problem. Fusarium species are the most common fungi associated with cereals all over the world. Among which F. verticillioides is the most frequently isolated species. FAO estimated that around 25-50% of cereals have been contaminated by mycotoxins. F. verticillioides produces secondary metabolites such as Fumonisins, trace level of fusaric acid, beauvericin, fusarin C, moniliformin, gibberiliformin in very low amount. Fumonisins receive the most attention as it is a potential carcinogen of global concern because they are the common contaminants of cereals and cereal-based foods. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) evaluated the toxin fumonisin as human carcinogen.
Keywords
• Fumonisins
• Pathogenic
• Metabolites
• Effects
• Fusarium verticillioides
Citation
Deepa N, Sreenivasa MY (2017) Fusarium verticillioides, a Globally Important Pathogen of Agriculture and Livestock: A Review. J Vet Med Res 4(4): 1084.
ABBREVATIONS
IARC: International Agency for Research on Cancer; FAO: Food and Agriculture Organization; PROMEC: Programme on Mycotoxins and Experimental Carcinogenesis; MRC: Medical Research Council; CSIR: Council for Scientific and Industrial Research.
INTRODUCTION
Fusarium verticillioide (Saccardo) Nirenberg (telomorph Gibberellamoniliformis Wineland) is an important plant pathogen with a wide range of hosts such as maize, sorghum, rice, millet, infecting plants in all stages of development, from the early hours of kernel germination to the time of harvest, including post-harvest deterioration of grains [1]. Seed infection by F. verticillioides is of major concern because it can reduce seed quality and result in contamination of grain with mycotoxins. Fusarium verticillioides infection of kernels occurs after flowering and is favored by hot and dry conditions. The fungus is distributed throughout the world, but predominant in humid tropical and subtropical regions and also present in the temperate regions [2,3]. In addition to causing plant diseases, infection by F. verticillioides can also result in contamination of kernels by fumonisins which can cause food safety problems for humans and animals and these fumonisins cannot easily be detoxified or removed from the grains [4,5].
TAXONOMY AND MORPHOLOGY
Fusarium verticillioides belongs to the section Liseola of Fusarium genus. In 1976, Helgard Nirenberg rejected F. moniliforme and transferred Oospora verticillioides to F. verticillioides (Sacc.) Nirenberg, while retaining Saccardo as the original author, and the epithet “verticillioides” which described the whorled nature (i.e., verticillate or cyclic) of the conidiophores [6] and it has been defined as mating population A of the Fusarium fujikuroi species complex (formally known as Gibberellafujikuroi species complex) [7].
The taxonomical relationship of Fusarium verticillioidesis as follows: Kingdom Fungi, Class Deuteromycetes, Order Moniliales, Family Tuberculariaceae and genus Fusarium. Name of the taxon was highly controversial among the taxonomists as F. moniliforme and F. verticillioides. Presently the name F. verticillioides has been generally accepted and been in practise in the routine days [7]. The name F. verticillioides should be used only for strains that have the G. monoliformis (Gibberellafujikuroi mating population) telomorph and not simply as a replacement for F. moniliforme(Synder and Hansen). F. moniliforme is now likely called as F. thapsinum from sorghum, F. sacchari from sugar cane, F. mangiferae from mango, and F. fujikuroi from rice [5].
Fusarium verticillioides produces initially white mycelia but later develop into violet pigments with age. Macroconidia are long, slender, straight, thin walled, apically curved and notched basally with 3 to 5 septate and difficult to find. Abundant Microconidia are oval in shape, 0 septate, long chains of microconidia arise from monophialides and occasionally produces pair of rabbit ear shape of spores are observed. Chlamydospores are absent, swollen cells in some isolated species will be mistaken as pseudochlamydospores [5].
Fusarium verticillioides is morphologically similar to Fusarium thapsium which do not produce yellow pigment and Fusarium proliferatum which produce short chain of microconidiacan be differentiated by molecular markers, production of spores and pigments. F. verticillioides is very similar to F. andiyazibut does not form pseudochlamydospores. F. verticillioides is similar in some respects to F. nygamai which forms microconidia in short chains or false heads from monophialides, abundant macroconidia in sporodochia and chlamydospores in the aerial hyphae in older cultures [8].
HOST AND DISTRIBUTION
Fusarium verticillioides is widely distributed throughout the world and is particularly associated with Maize [9,10], rice [11- 13], sugarcane [14], wheat [15], banana [16], asparagus[17,18] and sorghum [19]. High incidence of F. verticillioides was found in poultry feed mixtures and in animal feeds based on maize pellets and wheat bran [20]. A total of 51 cereal samples were found to be associated with F. Verticillioides with 33.12% of percent incidence in maize [21]. F. verticillioides were particularly associated with maize causes stalk rot and cob rot with drastic decrease of grain quality resulting in yield loss. The brutality of the rottness is affected by mode of inoculation systemically initiating from different routes such as seed or kernel through wounds in plant or infections of silks reciting disease symptoms [22,23].
The resistant genotypes are studied by the molecular mechanisms of the host response to infection which have been recently elucidated in maize and the identification of resistant genotypes will contribute to reduce fumonisin contamination. Developing Genetic resistance in maize to F. Verticillioides is of high priority in which sources of resistance has been identified and incorporated into public and private breeding programs [3]. Lanubile et al. [24], reported transcriptional changes were studied by next-generation RNA-sequencing for the first time with F. verticillioides in resistant C0441 and susceptible C0354 maize genotypes which revealed 6,951 differently expressed genes. Very recently Ju et al.[25], in Aprildocumented 8 quantitative trait loci (QTLs) and 43 genes associated with 57 SNPs correlated with F. verticillioides stalk rot resistance through linkage mapping and genome wide association analysis respectively. Similarly, Maschietto et al. [26], accelerated the resistance of maize lines by using identified set of QTLs and candidate genes for reducing disease severity and lowering mycotoxin contamination by F. verticillioides.
The quantity of stalk rot usually increases by drought stress and is reassured by irrigation. Many plants have at least one Fusarium associated diseases. Ear rot severity highness is due to disordered husk [27]. F. verticillioides infection is more susceptible among High lysine corn, brown midrib corn and sweet corn lines causing root rot with decreased root growth in maize seedlings [28,29]. F. verticillioides causes foot rot disease in rice; crown rot among asparagus and top rot in sugar cane and also infects many plant species, and has been reconfirmed that the infection is by F. verticillioides but not by the other G. fujikori species complex [30] (Table 1).
PHYSIOLOGY AND BIOCHEMISTRY
F. verticillioides growth is reported to occur at 25º C and an osmotic potential of -1.0 MPa with the best growth occurring on wounded immature reproductive tissues. Fumonisin B1 production will also be high at this condition in the laboratory [31-33]. Biochemically many number of enzymes from F. verticillioides have been examined like ß-d-Galactosidase [34], Dextranase [35], D-lactonohydrolase [36], pectate lyase [37,38], peptidase [39], phosphatases [40], polygalacturonase [41-43], oxygenase [44], proteases [45], ribonucleases [46] and ß-xylosidase [47]. F. verticillioides strains are commercially used to resolve DL-pantolactone mixtures since some strains can degrade lactic acid containing polymers [48,49]. Gonzalez-Jaen et al. [50], demonstrated that genes Fum1 (=Fum5), Fum6, and Fum8 were only present in F. verticillioides and other Fusarium species as the principle producers of fumonisins within the G. fujikuroi complex. Sanchez-Rangel et al. [51], reported similar results with a different pair of primers with presence or absence of the Fum1 gene which is the principle ability of a F. verticillioides isolate to produce fumonisin. Ramana et al. [52], system was based on the Fum1 and Fum13 gene sequences of F. proliferatum and F. verticillioides and was applied to the detection of the fungi in artificially contaminated cornmeal in a multiplex PCR assay.
Ma et al. [53], studied the genome statistics of F. verticillioides strain 7600 with NCBI accession number of AAIM02000000 and genome size of 41.7Mb comprising of 8 sequence coverage folds, 11 chromosomes, 31 scaffolds, 14,179 coding genes with 1,397bp median gene length and 0.36Mb repetitive sequence, 0.14% of transposable elements.
Table 1: Fusarium verticillioides infection causing diseases in the crop.
Sl. No. |
Crop | Disease | Reference |
1. | Coconut palm (Cocos nucifera) |
Bud rot | Ploetz R et al., 1999 |
2. | Corn/Maize (Zea mays) |
Fusarium ear rot, stalk rot, kernel rot, root rot, seed rot, Seedling blight, seedling root rot |
Shurtleff M.C et al., 1993 |
3. | Pearl millet (Pennisetumglauccum) |
Top rot | Wilson J.P et al., 1996 |
4. | Sorghum (Sorghum bicolor) |
Fusarium wilt head blight, root rot, stalk rot, Seedling blight and seed rot |
Horne C.W et al., 1993 |
5. | Sugarcane (Saccharum spp.) |
Fusarium stem rot and twisted top |
Ferreira S.A. et al., 1993 |
6. | Sunflower (Helianthus annus) |
Fusarium stalk rot | Gulya T.J et al., 1993 |
Source: www. apsnet.org/online/common/search.asp |
SECONDARY METABOLITES
Secondary metabolites are generally produced by all Fusarium species, but some mycotoxins are toxic to humans and animals. To date, 28 structurally related fumonisin analogues have been identified, only three of them fumonisin B1 (FB1), B2 and B3 occur abundantly, Fusaric acid and fusarin C is produced in very sensitive levels as of zinc and manganese occurs at fermentation time, trace levels of beauveriacin, Gibberellin and moniliformin are produced not more than trace levels by F. verticillioides [54]. Among the Fusarium species F. verticillioides is the most prominent Fusarium species that produces the most important toxins fumonisins, discovered in the cultures of F. moniliforme (= F. verticillioides) [55,2].
FUMONISINS AND ITS TYPES
During the mid-1980s, although their effects on horses had been recognized for at least 150 years before with a significant risk of contamination to the association of F. verticillioides species with cereals and cereal based feeds [57,58]. During the last two and half decade, fumonisins have received worldwide attention. In 1988, the fumonisins were first isolated at the Programme on Mycotoxins and Experimental Carcinogenesis (PROMEC) of the Medical Research Council (MRC) in Tygerberg, South Africa, by Gelderblomet al [55]. Also in the same year, the structures of the fumonisins were also elucidated in a collaborative effort between the PROMEC and the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) in Pretoria [59]. Fumonisins are a group of 15 closely related mycotoxins that frequently occur in maize and other cereal based foods produced by 15 Fusarium species such as F. verticillioides, F. proliferatum, F. subglutinans, F. thapsinum, F. anthophilum, F. globosum, F. fujikuroi, F. sacchari. F. nygami, F. dlamini, F. napiforme, F. andiyazi, F. pseudonygami, F. oxysporum and F. Polyphialidicum [56].
Fumonisins receive the most attention because they are the common contaminants of cereals and cereal-based foods. They are ubiquitous in distribution and are found frequently on freshly harvested and stored agricultural commodities such as cereals in all stages of their production, processing and storage. Fumonisins are divided into four groups: A, B, C and G, with the B-type fumonisins being the most toxic. There are more than 10 fumonisins, but only three, FB1 , FB2 and FB3 , occur naturally [60]. Fumonisin B1 is considered as the most serious threat to human and animal health and has been reported that FB1 makes up approximately 70%, and FB2 and FB3 each make up about 10–20% of the total fumonisin content [57,61]. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) evaluated the fumonisins as Group 2B carcinogens i.e. possibly carcinogenic to humans [62,63].
The chemical structure of fumonisins (Figure 1) was elucidated and named them as fumonisin B1 (FB1 ) and fumonisin B2 (FB2 ) respectively [55,59]. The fumonisin optimally produces at moderate water activity and with nitrogen limited and usually its production doubles roughly for every 48 hrs with increase in mycelial dry weight. Cultures of F. moniliforme MRC 826 on maize were used to isolate and to study the structure of the fumonisins. A few years later FB3 and FB4 were also isolated and characterized [64,65]. Fumonisin B1 is a white hydroscopic powder that is soluble in water, acetonitrile-water or methanol and has the empirical formula C34H59NO15 (relative molecular mass: 721). Fumonisins B1 and B2 are stable in methanol if stored at –18º C but steadily degrade at 25º C and above. However, they are reported to be stable over a 6- month period at 25º C in acetonitrile-water (1:1). Fumonisin B1 is the diester of propane-1, 2, 3-tricarboxylicacid and 2S-amino-12S, 16R-dimethyl-3S, 5R, 10R, 14S, 15R-pentahydroxyeicosane in which the C-14 and C-15 hydroxy groups are esterified with the terminal carboxy group of propane-1, 2, 3-tricarboxylic acid. FB2 to FB4 show different hydroxylation patterns.
FUMONISIN DISTRIBUTION, METABOLISM AND ITS AFFECTS
Fumonisins appears to be wide spread in U.S. maize [66]. Surveys of 1,300 maize samples collected in the central United States from 1988 through 1995 indicated low levels of FB1 [67]. Cereals and cereal based products from maize source are the main commodities with natural FB1 occurrence have been reported from all parts of the world such as Brazil, Asia, Italy, Costa Rica and Hungary respectively [68-72]. In India, high levels of FB1 were reported in maize kernels infected with F. moniliforme [73,74]and in maize as well as poultry feeds [75]. Fumonisin B1 contamination of maize and poultry feeds was high in Haryana, with 91 out of 100 maize samples and 42 out of 50 poultry feed samples were found to be contaminated with fumonisin B1. Fumonisins were considered as their occurrence was only confined to maize and later their presence was noted in a range of products, which include rice [76,77], sorghum [75,78,79] and low levels in wheat, barley, soybean [80] and at very low level in beer [81,82]. Recently fumonisin producing F. verticillioides was detected and differentiated from non fumonisin producing strains through nested and multiplex PCR as an early detection methods [83,84].
The secondary metabolite fumonisins include the polyketide pigment bikaverin, the terpenoid plant growth regulators gibberellic acids (GAs), and multiple mycotoxins. Nelson et al. [31], reported that Fumonisin toxicity is thought to result from the blockage of sphingolipid biosynthesis [85]. Sphingolipids have a complex role in cell function by affecting a number of metabolic processes due to fumonisins. Accumulation of sphingolipid bases leads to inhibition of growth cells resulting in cytotoxicity. They can inhibit protein kinase-C, activate phospholipase D, activate or inhibit enzymes involved in lipid signalling pathways, inhibit Na+/K+ ATPase, and induce dephosphorylation of retinoblastoma protein. All of these processes may increase cancer risk via loss of regulation of differentiation, apoptosis and lipid mediators that control cell proliferation [86-88]. Ceramide synthase inhibition generally results in accumulation of free sphinganine in liver, lung and kidney.Sphinganine, as a hydrophobic compound, can cross cell membranes and occur in blood and in urine if the kidneys are affected [89,87]. As the proposed mechanisms of action involve alterations in de novo synthesis, nutritional factors might be important in toxic end-points. The liver is the target for FB1 in all animals and the kidney is also a target in many animals. Initially fumonisin B induced toxicity is characterized by increase in apoptotic, oncotic necrosis and regeneration in kidney and bile duct hyperplasia is reported in liver. Fumonisin B1 toxicity depends on strain and sex of the rodents [31].
Marasaset al. [90], reported the first syndrome of fumonisins, ELEM, equine leukoencephalomalacia, in 1980s characterized by fatal necrotic lesions in the cerebrum in horses. Smith et al. [91], reported that fumonisins induce cardiovascular dysfunction in horses with decreased heart rates, lower cardiac output, and right ventricular contractibility which may be involved in the pathogenesis of the lesions in the central nervous system. The symptoms in swine have been referred to as Porcine Pulmonary Edema (PPE) characterized by pulmonary, cardiovascular and hepatic symptoms as a “mystery swine disease” with diarrhea, weight loss, increased liver weight and poor performance [92] (Table 2).
Toxicity of FB1 has been implicated affecting alligators [93], fresh water fish [94] causing hepatotoxicity in rats [95] with skin lesions [96], wounds [97], keratitis [98],Polycystic kidney disease (PKD)mainly affecting liver, kidney and lungs in animals and life threatening cancer disease in humans [55](Table 2). Subsequent studies have also shown that fumonisins are toxic to plants causing root rot, stem rot, seed rot, seedling blight, head blight diseases which has been explained in table one [77]. It is known to be allergic to humans systematically infecting cancer and HIV patients and not associated with hospital settings but nosocomial diseases do occur [99-102,109]. F. verticillioides is resistant to most clinical antifungals like itraconazole, miconazole, amphotericin B [103] and flucytosine [104] reported as most effective.
CONCLUSION
Fusarium verticilliodes is genetically the most intensively studied species in the section of Fusarium. This fungus is primarily a pathogen of maize and other crops like sorghum and largely responsible for important economic losses worldwide. F. verticillioides is mainly known to produce fumonisins which is well studied in terms of its synthesis, its effects on animals and humans that consumes contaminated grains its association with disruption of sphingolipid metabolism and folate transport which is a potential risk factor for human neural tubes. Hence it is a thrust area in food safety research for its prevention.
Table 2: Effects of fumonisins on humans and animals.
Affected | After effects | Source |
Horse | CNS, ELEM (Equine Leukoencephalomalacia) |
Smith et al., [90] |
Swine | PPE, Hepatotoxicosis, lesions in liver, lung targets to Pancreas, heart, oesophagus |
Hollinger &Ekperigin [92] |
Rats | Hepatic nodules, adenofibrosis, hepatocellular carcinoma, cholangiocarcinoma, hepatotoxins |
Gross et al.,[105] |
Rabbit | Anorectic, lethargic, injures liver and kidney |
Gumprechtet al., [106] |
Chiken | Erythrocyte formation, lymphocyte cytotoxic effects, weight reduction, hepatic necrosis, biliary hyperplasia, thymic cortical atrophy. |
Javid et al., [107] |
Primates | Oesophagal cancer, reduction in WBC and RBC |
Gelderblomet al., [108] |
Humants | Esophageal cancer, skin lesions, wounds, keratitis. |
Kyung et al., [109] |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We wish to thank Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) for awarding Senior Research Fellowship (SRF)as financial support to carry out the research work on Fusarium verticillioides and its management.